Pregunta 1 de 36
It's Time to End Library Late Fines
An opinion column by a retired librarian in the fictional town of Millbrook
(1) For most of my thirty years as a librarian in Millbrook, I collected late fines without thinking twice. A dime a day seemed like a small price for keeping books moving. I was wrong. The Millbrook Public Library Board will vote next month on whether to eliminate overdue fines, and I urge every board member to vote yes.
(2) Fines do not do what we hoped they would do. Several libraries that have dropped fines report that most books still come back, and some report that more come back, because patrons who were embarrassed by a large balance return to the library once the debt is gone. When our own branch held a one-month "fine-free amnesty" in 2022, more than 1,100 overdue items were returned, some of them years late.
(3) Fines also fall hardest on the people who need the library most. A family with a few dollars to spare pays a fine and moves on. A family living paycheck to paycheck may stop coming altogether. In Millbrook, a balance of just $10 blocks a card from checking out materials. I have watched children leave the desk empty-handed because of a fine their parents could not pay. No library mission statement says "for those who can afford it."
(4) Some board members worry that without fines, patrons will keep books forever and the library will lose needed income. These concerns are understandable, and I shared them once. But fines brought in less than one percent of last year's library budget, and staff spent many hours collecting and tracking them, hours that could go to story times and job-search help. Under the proposal, patrons who never return an item would still be billed for its replacement cost. Responsibility would remain; only the penalty for lateness would disappear.
(5) A library's job is to put books in people's hands, not to keep them out. Ending late fines is a small change that would welcome back hundreds of our neighbors. Board members, please vote yes.
What is the author's main purpose in writing this column?
Pista
Look at the first and last paragraphs. What does the author ask someone to do?
Solución paso a paso
The author states her purpose directly in paragraph 1: "The Millbrook Public Library Board will vote next month on whether to eliminate overdue fines, and I urge every board member to vote yes." She repeats it at the very end: "Board members, please vote yes."
Everything in between supports that request: evidence that fines don't work (paragraph 2), that they hurt low-income families (paragraph 3), and an answer to the board's concerns (paragraph 4). A text that gives reasons and asks readers to take an action is written to persuade.
The correct answer is C.
The column does include some information about fines, but informing is not the main goal; the information is there to win votes. The author mentions her career only briefly to show her experience, not to entertain. And nothing explains how to return books.
Tip: To find an author's purpose, check the opening and closing paragraphs. Words like I urge, should, please vote or we must signal a persuasive purpose.
La explicación todavía no está traducida. Abrir en Google Traductor ↗