Question 1 of 10 · Main idea, details and summary
Opinion: Give Apprenticeships a Seat at the Table
(1) Every spring at Lakeview High School, where I have worked as a counselor for fourteen years, we hold a college signing day. Seniors stand on the gym stage in sweatshirts from the schools they will attend, and the crowd cheers. It is a wonderful tradition. But every year I notice who is not on that stage: the students who have accepted paid apprenticeships as electricians, machinists, medical assistants and welders. They have made a plan for their future that is every bit as serious, yet we act as if they have made no plan at all.
(2) That silence sends a message, and students hear it. Over the years, many of my students have told me they were interested in a trade but worried that their parents or friends would see it as "settling." Some of them enrolled in college programs they had little interest in, took on loans and left after a semester or two. Others chose the trade anyway but felt they had to apologize for it.
(3) The truth is that apprenticeships are not a lesser path. In a typical apprenticeship, a person works for an employer, earns a paycheck from the first day and takes classes at the same time. Wages usually rise as skills grow. At the end, the apprentice holds a recognized credential and, in many cases, a job offer. For students who learn best by doing, this combination of work and study can be a far better fit than four more years in a classroom.
(4) Some parents worry that a trade will limit their child's choices later. It is a fair concern, but it misunderstands how careers work today. Many electricians and machinists go on to become supervisors, inspectors or business owners. Some later earn college degrees, often with their employer's help. Choosing an apprenticeship at eighteen does not close a door; it opens one that many students never knew was there.
(5) None of this means college is a bad choice. For many students it is exactly the right one. My point is simpler: we should treat every serious plan with the same respect. Schools can do this without spending much money. Invite apprentices to walk across the stage on signing day. Bring local employers and union training programs to career fairs alongside colleges. Teach students and parents how apprenticeships work, just as we teach them how to fill out a financial aid form.
(6) Our students are watching what we celebrate. If we want them to choose the path that fits them best, we have to show them that more than one path is worth cheering for.
What does the counselor most want to accomplish by writing this opinion piece?
Hint
Ask what the author wants readers to do after reading. Look for specific suggestions.
Step-by-step solution
Where the answer comes from: the author identifies a problem (apprentices are ignored on signing day, paragraph 1), explains its effect on students (paragraph 2), argues apprenticeships are valuable (paragraphs 3–4) and then calls for action: "Invite apprentices to walk across the stage on signing day. Bring local employers and union training programs to career fairs alongside colleges." (paragraph 5).
Step by step:
- Is the article mainly telling facts or arguing for a change? It argues — it uses "should" and gives commands ("Invite…", "Bring…", "Teach…").
- Who is being asked to change? Schools and the community.
- Which choice matches the whole piece?
Correct answer: to persuade schools to recognize and support apprenticeships as a respected choice after high school.
Check: the author describes signing day but does not want to cancel it; explains how apprenticeships work but only as support for the argument; mentions loans but is not mainly warning about debt.
Tip: an argument's purpose is usually to persuade. Commands and "should" statements near the end reveal exactly what the author wants.